README.md

mkit-sign-se — Apple Secure Enclave signer for mkit

mkit-sign-se is a Swift binary that implements the mkit external signer v1 wire protocol (docs/specs/SPEC-EXTERNAL-SIGNER.md) backed by Apple's Secure Enclave.

Headline properties:

• P-256 only. The Secure Enclave supports no other algorithm. Any SignRequest with a non-P-256 algorithm is answered with an Error frame carrying ERROR_CODE_UNSUPPORTED_ALGORITHM — this signer will not fall back to a software key.
• Non-extractable private key. SecureEnclave.P256.Signing.PrivateKey generates and holds the scalar inside the Secure Enclave processor; the blob persisted to the keychain is an encrypted handle that only the SEP on the same physical device can reconstitute.
• Optional biometric gating. --require-biometric on keygen binds the key to .biometryCurrentSet, so every sign prompts for Touch ID/Face ID (and the key becomes unusable if the user enrolls a new fingerprint/face). When the user cancels the prompt the signer returns ERROR_CODE_USER_DECLINED.

Wire protocol

mkit-sign-se sign speaks the v1 wire — length-prefixed protobuf SignerFrame messages on stdin/stdout. This is the same protocol all other mkit reference signers (mkit-sign-file, mkit-sign-tpm, mkit-sign-ctap) speak; the schema is shared (signer.proto plus common.proto).

The Swift implementation links the canonical Apple-platform protobuf runtime — SwiftProtobuf, pinned to 1.30.0+ in Package.swift. Pre-generated .pb.swift sources are checked into Sources/mkit-sign-se/Generated/ to avoid build-time codegen (SwiftPM has no clean equivalent of build.rs).

These are the same bindings any third-party signer integrator gets by running buf generate against the published buf.build/officialunofficial/mkit-rpc BSR module (issue #719) — no vendored mkit checkout or hand-rolled protoc invocation required. rust/crates/mkit-rpc/proto/buf.gen.yaml is the checked-in recipe; mkit-sign-se's own copy is refreshed the same way, via scripts/regen-mkit-sign-se-swift.sh. To regenerate after a .proto change:

$ brew install buf              # https://buf.build/docs/installation
$ ./scripts/regen-mkit-sign-se-swift.sh   # from the repo root

(Equivalent to running buf generate rust/crates/mkit-rpc/proto --template rust/crates/mkit-rpc/proto/buf.gen.yaml and copying the common/signer outputs into Generated/ — no protoc or protoc-gen-swift install needed; buf fetches the Swift plugin as a remote plugin execution.)

Capabilities

algorithms = [P256]
key_forms  = [OPAQUE_HANDLE]   # UTF-8 bytes of the keychain tag
supports_pin = false
supports_certificate_chain = false
requires_user_presence = true   # advisory — biometric or keychain prompt

Resolving the key

The Secure Enclave key to sign with is selected by tag — the same label keygen stored under kSecAttrAccount. The tag can be supplied two ways:

• --tag <label> on argv (per-process default).
• SignRequest.key_ref over the wire, interpreted as the UTF-8 bytes of the tag (KEY_FORM_OPAQUE_HANDLE per signer.proto).

When both are set, the wire value wins. If neither is set the signer answers with ERROR_CODE_INVALID_REQUEST.

Requirements

• macOS 12 (Monterey) or later.
• Apple Silicon, or an Intel Mac with a T2 security chip. (Check with swift -e 'import CryptoKit; print(SecureEnclave.isAvailable)'.)
• Swift 5.9+ toolchain — shipping Xcode 14+ or the standalone Command Line Tools is enough.
• For the e2e test: openssl and python3 (both ship with macOS).
• SwiftProtobuf 1.30+ is fetched automatically by SwiftPM on first build; no manual setup needed.

Build

$ swift build -c release
$ ls .build/release/mkit-sign-se
.build/release/mkit-sign-se

Or via the Makefile:

$ make build

Install

$ make install                      # copies to /usr/local/bin
$ make install PREFIX=$HOME/.local  # installs under ~/.local/bin

The expected production install path is /usr/local/bin/mkit-sign-se; that is the path mkit's attest.external_signer_path config key should point at.

Usage

Subcommands:

mkit-sign-se keygen --tag <label> [--require-biometric]
mkit-sign-se sign   [--tag <label>]
mkit-sign-se list
mkit-sign-se delete --tag <label>

keygen

Mints a new SEP-backed P-256 key and stores it in the login keychain under <label>. Prints the p256:<66-hex> keyid to stdout so you can register it with an mkit trust-root registry.

$ mkit-sign-se keygen --tag my-attest-key
p256:033783333f45f68642c2df4d023a5e027ed0bf68f6ddd01506cdfe5b007456ca87

Add --require-biometric to gate signing on Touch ID/Face ID.

sign

Implements the v1 external-signer wire protocol. Reads framed SignerFrame messages from stdin and writes framed responses to stdout:

mkit -> signer:    SignerFrame{ Hello { protocol_version = V1, ... } }
signer -> mkit:    SignerFrame{ HelloResponse { capabilities... } }
mkit -> signer:    SignerFrame{ SignRequest { algorithm = P256, ... } }
signer -> mkit:    SignerFrame{ SignResponse { signature, public_key, key_id, ... } }

Each frame is a 4-byte little-endian u32 length prefix followed by the protobuf body, capped at 1 MiB matching MAX_FRAME_BYTES in rust/crates/mkit-rpc/src/framing.rs. The signer loops on stdin and processes successive Hello and SignRequest pairs until the caller closes the stream — a clean EOF on the length prefix is treated as a graceful shutdown.

Per-request errors (no key with that tag, biometric declined, unsupported algorithm) come back as Error frames; the binary keeps running. Setup-phase failures (no Secure Enclave on the host, bad argv) exit non-zero with a message on stderr and no frame on stdout.

list

Prints <tag>\t<compressed-pubkey-hex> for each key this binary owns. Useful after a keygen to sanity-check persistence, or on a clean machine to confirm nothing is stored yet.

delete

Removes a key by tag. Idempotent is NOT the contract: deleting an unknown tag exits non-zero with a tagNotFound message.

Wiring mkit to use it

.mkit/config:

[attest]
signer = "external"
external_signer_path = "/usr/local/bin/mkit-sign-se"
external_signer_args = "sign|--tag|my-attest-key"

The pipe (|) is used in the args string because commas are reserved for --additional-signer multi-sig specs. mkit splits on | and passes each piece as a separate argv element, so the signer is launched as mkit-sign-se sign --tag my-attest-key.

mkit keygen does NOT produce an SEP-backed key

mkit keygen --algorithm p256 writes a raw-key file to .mkit/signing.key — a different flow. For the SEP workflow:

1. Run mkit-sign-se keygen --tag my-attest-key to mint the SEP key.
2. Note the printed p256:<hex> keyid.
3. Add that keyid to your verifier's trust-root registry.
4. Configure mkit with the external_signer_* block above.

Security notes

• Non-extractable secret. The private scalar is generated inside the SEP and never leaves it. A full disk snapshot — or even a compromised kernel — cannot exfiltrate the key material; they can only ask the SEP to sign, subject to whatever access control was set at creation.
• Biometric-gated signing. With --require-biometric, signing prompts for Touch ID/Face ID. Canceling the prompt surfaces as an ERROR_CODE_USER_DECLINED frame.
• Device loss = key loss. SEP keys are bound to the physical SEP silicon. They are not synced via iCloud Keychain. A lost/ wiped/reset device loses the key irrecoverably — you cannot back it up. Export and record the public key (the p256:<hex> keyid) before you rely on the signer in production, and plan a key-rotation policy against device loss.
• One binary, one keychain. All keys this binary creates live under kSecAttrService = dev.mkit.mkit-sign-se; list shows only those. Deleting a key is reversible only if you kept the old dataRepresentation blob (this binary doesn't; it deletes the keychain item wholesale).
• Installation path. Treat attest.external_signer_path as a code-execution sink (same class as git config core.editor). For any deployment where the local user account is less trusted than the user who configured mkit, install the binary on a root-owned, non-user-writable path (for example /usr/local/bin/).

Troubleshooting

"Secure Enclave not available on this device"

You are on an Intel Mac without a T2, or inside a sandboxed/ container environment where SecureEnclave.isAvailable returns false. This signer refuses to fall back to a software key by design — use mkit-sign-file (the reference signer) for dev/CI, and the Apple signer only on hardware that has a real SEP.

"keychain error: -25308 (User interaction is not allowed.)"

The keychain is locked and the binary is running under a non-GUI session (for example SSH, LaunchDaemon, cron). Unlock your keychain, or mark the item as "always allow" the first time you use it interactively, or re-run under the same user session that created the key.

"keychain error: -25300 (The specified item could not be found.)"

The tag you passed to sign/delete doesn't exist. Run mkit-sign-se list to see what's there, or mkit-sign-se keygen --tag <label> to create it.

Got an ERROR_CODE_USER_DECLINED from sign

You pressed Cancel on the Touch ID/Face ID dialog, let it time out, or enrolled a new biometric after creating a --require-biometric key (that invalidates the key per .biometryCurrentSet). Re-create the key with a fresh keygen.

Code-signing for distribution

For Gatekeeper-approved distribution of this binary you'll need a Developer ID signature and notarization. Neither is needed for local development; swift build -c release produces a binary the running user can execute directly. For a signed build:

$ codesign --force --options runtime --sign "Developer ID Application: …" \
    .build/release/mkit-sign-se
$ xcrun notarytool submit .build/release/mkit-sign-se --wait …

Testing

$ swift test           # unit tests; SEP-roundtrip tests are XCTSkip'd
                       # if the SEP is unavailable
$ ./Tests/e2e.sh       # end-to-end: keygen -> sign (over the protobuf
                       # wire) -> openssl verify -> reject path -> delete

The e2e.sh script is self-contained: it assembles the request frames with a small python3 helper (no protobuf dependency — it encodes the varints by hand), pipes them through the signer, parses the response frames, and verifies the compact signature out-of-band with openssl. On a host without a SEP, the script prints a skip message and exits 0.

The script lives under Tests/e2e.sh rather than a separate tests/ directory so the same folder hosts both the XCTest sources and the shell e2e — and so the path works on case-insensitive macOS filesystems where Tests/ and tests/ are the same directory anyway.

Status

Reference Swift implementation of the v1 external-signer wire protocol. Companion to the Rust signers (mkit-sign-file, mkit-sign-tpm, mkit-sign-ctap) — same protocol, different language, different secret store.